Bay Street Players Schedule 2026

See upcoming events, concerts, schedules, and ticket prices at Bay Street Players.

Address: 109 N Bay St., Eustis, FL 32726

Bay Street Players hosts live shows, music, and seasonal events throughout the year. Check the latest schedule, compare ticket prices, and see what’s coming up next in Eustis, FL.

Updated: November 1, 2026
Best Seats Guide

31 Upcoming Events
$33 Tickets From
Live Event Venue Venue Type
2026 Current Schedule

On this page:

Schedule

Location

Best Seats

FAQ

All Events in Eustis

Upcoming Events at Bay Street Players

Browse the complete schedule of upcoming events at this venue

Nov 01, 2026, 2:00 PM Sun — MUSICAL / PLAY, Weekend Event: Carrie - The Musical at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $51, 18 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Nov 05, 2026, 7:30 PM Thu — MUSICAL / PLAY, Best Value: Carrie - The Musical at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $33, Avg. price ~ $47, 18 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Nov 06, 2026, 7:30 PM Fri — MUSICAL / PLAY: Carrie - The Musical at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $54, 14 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Nov 07, 2026, 2:00 PM Sat — MUSICAL / PLAY, Weekend Event: Carrie - The Musical at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $54, 18 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Nov 08, 2026, 2:00 PM Sun — MUSICAL / PLAY, Weekend Event: Carrie - The Musical at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $51, 24 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Nov 13, 2026, 7:30 PM Fri — MUSICAL / PLAY: Carrie - The Musical at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $53, Tickets Available: 35. Select Seats

Nov 14, 2026, 2:00 PM Sat — MUSICAL / PLAY, Weekend Event: Carrie - The Musical at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $54, 19 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Nov 15, 2026, 2:00 PM Sun — MUSICAL / PLAY, Weekend Event: Carrie - The Musical at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $56, 14 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Jan 15, 2027, 7:30 PM Fri — MUSICAL / PLAY: A Midsummer Night's Dream at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $56, 14 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Jan 16, 2027, 7:30 PM Sat — MUSICAL / PLAY, Weekend Event: A Midsummer Night's Dream at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $60, 20 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Jan 17, 2027, 2:00 PM Sun — MUSICAL / PLAY, Weekend Event: A Midsummer Night's Dream at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $53, 17 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Jan 21, 2027, 7:30 PM Thu — MUSICAL / PLAY, Best Value: A Midsummer Night's Dream at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $33, Avg. price ~ $48, 19 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Jan 22, 2027, 7:30 PM Fri — MUSICAL / PLAY: A Midsummer Night's Dream at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $57, 14 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Jan 23, 2027, 2:00 PM Sat — MUSICAL / PLAY, Weekend Event: A Midsummer Night's Dream at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $57, 14 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Jan 24, 2027, 2:00 PM Sun — MUSICAL / PLAY, Weekend Event: A Midsummer Night's Dream at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $50, 25 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Jan 29, 2027, 7:30 PM Fri — MUSICAL / PLAY: A Midsummer Night's Dream at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $57, 14 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Jan 30, 2027, 2:00 PM Sat — MUSICAL / PLAY, Weekend Event: A Midsummer Night's Dream at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $55, 19 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Jan 31, 2027, 2:00 PM Sun — MUSICAL / PLAY, Weekend Event: A Midsummer Night's Dream at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $57, 14 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Apr 02, 2027, 7:30 PM Fri — MUSICAL / PLAY: Peter and the Starcatcher at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $60, 20 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Apr 03, 2027, 7:30 PM Sat — MUSICAL / PLAY, High Demand, Weekend Event: Peter and the Starcatcher at Bay Street Players, Eustis, FL, US. From $41, Avg. price ~ $70, 24 tickets remaining! Select Seats

Load More Events

Bay Street Players Location

Bay Street Players is a Entertainment Venue in Eustis, FL

FAQ about Bay Street Players

Quick answers on tickets, seats, parking, and what to expect.

How much are tickets at Bay Street Players?

Depends on the event, honestly. Weeknight shows and smaller games are usually cheaper, while big concerts, rivalry games, and playoffs can get expensive fast. Prices move around a lot once demand picks up in Eustis.

Where are the best seats at Bay Street Players?

Most people go for center sections if they can. Lower levels feel closer to the action, while mid-level seats usually give the best overall view without spending a fortune.

Are upper-level seats still worth it?

Yeah, for sure. Modern arenas and stadiums in Eustis are built so the view stays decent almost everywhere. You’re farther back, obviously, but still totally fine for most events.

What time should I get there?

Showing up about an hour early is usually the safe move. Security lines, parking, grabbing food, and finding your section around Bay Street Players can take longer than people expect.

Is parking available at Bay Street Players?

Usually, yeah. Most venues around Eustis have nearby lots, garages, or rideshare drop-off spots. Bigger events can get pretty backed up after the show, especially on weekends.

Do seats feel different depending on the event?

Definitely. A concert setup is totally different from basketball, hockey, football, or comedy. Same section can feel amazing one night and just okay the next depending on the stage or crowd setup.